For his career, Nicholson scored 17 goals and registered seven assists (41 points) in 83 career games. His sophomore season he established himself as one of the top defensive players in the country and his last two seasons, he shifted to the mid-field and became more of an offensive threat, scoring six goals and six assists (18 points) as a junior.
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown | Previous School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 00 | Jonathan Viscosi | FR | GK | 6-2 | Ottawa, CAN | All Saints Catholic High School | |
| 1 | Jordan Lower | SO | GK | 6-1 | South Webster, OH | South Webster High School | |
| 2 | Jordan Shepard | FR | MF/D | 5-7 | Doncaster, England | ||
| 3 | Steven O'Hara | JR | DEF | 5-10 | Liverpool, England | Prescott Comprehensive School | |
| 4 | Sam Fairhurst | SO | MF | 6-2 | Wigan, England | St. Edmund Arrowsmith High School | |
| 5 | Joel Thiessen | SO | FWD | 5-8 | Newcastle, Australia | University of New Mexico | |
| 6 | Neil Harries | SO | MF/F | 6-3 | Lancashire, England | St. Mary's College | |
| 7 | Stuart Croft | SR | MF | 5-11 | Wigan, England | St. John Rugby College | |
| 8 | Tim Marcinek | SR | FWD | 5-11 | Jackson, OH | Jackson High School | |
| 9 | Chris Anderson | JR | MF | 5-11 | Lancaster, England | Lancaster College | |
| 10 | Ederson Lopes | JR | MF | 6-1 | Sao Paulo, Brazil | Colegio Dimensia | |
| 11 | Jon Brooks | SR | MF | 5-8 | Blackburn, England | Cardinal Stritch University | |
| 12 | Marc Young | SR | DEF | 6-1 | Rishton, England | St. Christopher High School | |
| 14 | Dylan Williams | JR | MF | 5-7 | Bangor, Wales | Friars High School | |
| 15 | Drew McCaffery | JR | MF | 5-10 | Ashland, KY | Paul Blazer High School | |
| 16 | Oliver Hewitt-Fisher | FR | MF/F | 5-9 | Swansea, Wales | Neath Port Talbot College | |
| 17 | Phil Stansfield | JR | MF | 5-7 | Yorkshire, England | Benton Park High School | |
| 18 | Nick Hewison | JR | DEF | 6-2 | Accrington, England | Hollins High School | |
| 19 | Scott Bibby | FR | FWD | 5-11 | Doncaster, England | Edlington Comprehensive | |
| 20 | Rafael Maccauro | FR | F/MF | 5-9 | Sao Paulo, Brazil | ||
| 21 | Corey Barker | FR | FWD | 5-8 | Russell, KY | Russell High School | |
| 22 | Codi Crippen | SR | MF | 5-10 | Zanesville, OH | Maysville High School | |
| 23 | Richard Isberner | FR | F/MF | 6-1 | Sao Paulo, Brazil | E.E. Oswaldo Aranha | |
| 24 | Konstantine Pyankov | SO | MF | 5-8 | Grove City, OH | Grove City High School | |
| 25 | Jack Marchant | SO | GK | 6-1 | Leeds, England |